E – Banking: Challenges
and Development in India
Mrs. Debashree Chakraborty
Assistant Professor of Law,
ITM-University, Raipur
*Corresponding Author E-mail: cdebotuli@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
The changing financial landscape has posed
new challenges for banks and policymakers/supervisors. Banks now have increased
reliance on technology to compete in an increasingly competitive business
environment and thus need to effectively manage the IT security and other
related risks. Central Banks and supervisory authorities are facing new
challenges in banking supervision as well as in designing and implementing
monetary policy. The growing scope of E-Banking and increasing complexity of
banking products and services demands continuous adaptation of regulatory
framework and effective supervisory oversight.
In India, there are guidelines or legal frame work for regulating the
system and try to control the risks. Reserve Bank of India and judiciary took
number of steps and frame rules and regulation so that there should not exist
any lacuna in regulating the system. And they are always in a position to
satisfy the need of the hour for that they occasionally amend laws and even
frame laws. Still in India, due to the system it can be traced out that along
with the development of economy, country facing various problems like cyber
crime and other frauds.
KEY WORDS: E-Banking System, Bank, Booms
and Banes of E-Banking system, Reserve bank of India, Cyber Laws.
With the change in the time the rise of the new internet era has
contributed a lot in the life style of the people living on the earth. Internet
is bringing so many changes in people’s life that they can get whatever they
think by sitting at home and without making any efforts. This is the benefit of
using internet. Almost all the banks in the world are providing the online
facility that includes from day to day transactions to account opening, issuing
credit cards paying and getting the loans and debts and providing customers
facilities to shop online. Some banks are also providing facilities to draw
cash from their bank accounts online and they can pay their bills online. Now
this is what one will call the revolution because the online E-Banking is the best
part about using the internet. With the use of online banks, one feels secure
and by sitting at home and one can do his monetary transaction and he do not
need to go to bank time after time.
Just log in to the website of
his bank and enter his account number and that is it. We can get access to all
the offers provided by banks to his customers and we can perform our desire
task about our bank account.
The offer remains the same as
they are for physical customers and sometimes banks offer more to people who
deal online with their accounts. Sometimes the customer has problem to get
access to their account instantly and they cannot afford to go to their bank.
At that time the online-Banking facility seems best to them for performing
their monetary action that they required. All the international banks like RBS,
Barclays, Standard Charters and State bank of America, JSB bank and many other
famous and local banks have the online websites that provides facilities for
customers to get connected with the banks from their homes, offices or even outside
the country. This service also provides you with facility to open a new account
online. You can get online forms and you have to fill the form and submit them.
When you will have an online account with banks, they deal with your other
matters and you are free of worries to go bank to solve your money problems.
That is why the concept of online-Banking is getting better day by day.
E-Banking now days are the
common trend in our country. No more falling in line in banks, no more waiting
tons of hours in the banks in the bank, no more days and weeks of waiting. All
can be done with one card, one gadget. It’s easy, it works, and most
importantly, people like it. But still some people are having a hard time using
this kind of technology mostly people who are used to do things the old
traditional way. With the use of advertising, people are now motivated to use –
E- Banking because again, it eliminates the hassle encountered when using the
old process of banking.
This changing financial
landscape has posed new challenges for banks and policymakers/supervisors.
Banks now have increased reliance on technology to compete in an increasingly
competitive business environment and thus need to effectively manage the IT
security and other related risks. Central Banks and supervisory authorities are
facing new challenges in banking supervision as well as in designing and
implementing monetary policy. The growing scope of E-Banking and increasing
complexity of banking products and services demands continuous adaptation of
regulatory framework and effective supervisory oversight.
‘Each and every coin has two sides”, like that
E-Banking system provides lots of advantages and also it is very much
beneficial for the growth of economy of a country rapidly. But there are number
of disadvantages which ultimately resulted to be a challenge. Security issues
and different impacts regarding the traditional banking method and also
concerned about the issues presented because think that these issues are very
important and relevant today, a lot of people save money.2 Even, through due to E-Banking system there
are number of challenges which are facing by India and try to related with
existing laws which regulating E-Banking system in India is up to mark or not,
as because now a days, there is increase position in Cyber - Crime. Thus,
Electronic banking is the wave of the future. It provides enormous benefits to
consumers in terms of the ease and cost of transactions. But it also poses new
challenges for country authorities in regulating and supervising the financial
system and in designing and implementing macroeconomic policy.
E-Banking
system is a basic trend of the financial institutions or banks of every country
whether developed country or developing country for their up benefit. Each and
every country of the globe has their respective rules or regulations related to
handing the procedure of E-Banking system. This may cause difference between
them. Due to this some country facing some challenges or some country is in a
position to carry on the system systematically with full security.
In
India, there are guidelines or legal frame work for regulating the system and
try to control the risks. Reserve Bank of India and judiciary took number of
steps and frame rules and regulation so that there should not exist any lacuna
in regulating the system. And they are always in a position to satisfy the need
of the hour for that they occasionally amend laws and even frame laws. Still in
India, due to the system it can be traced out that along with the development
of economy, country facing various problems like cyber crime and other frauds.
In
the entire globe, where the wave of electronic mechanism of banking is creating
revolutionary changes and inviting easy way for both customers and bankers to
carry on their money business, India,
still in an uprising stage. System of E-Banking in India is creeping and
making its shape in a manner which is still not satisfactory. There are many
episodes of E-Banking which are still missing its prudence in India and which
has its own present work is that, through E-Banking is a gift of ease to
the-Banking system it is far from its full form in India. Thus to employ the
system in its fullest form lacunas need to be removed and up dated process need
to be installed.
E-Banking System: Concept and Its Starting Era
People
earn money to meet their day-to-day expenses and also to save money for future
expenses. With this practice, savings were available for use whenever needed,
but it also involved the risk of loss by theft, robbery and other accidents.
Thus, people were in need of a place where money could be saved safely and
would be available when required. Banks are such places where people can
deposit their savings with the assurance that they will be able to withdraw
money from the deposits whenever required. People who wish to borrow money for
business and other purposes can also get loans from the banks at reasonable
rate of interest.
Bank
is a lawful organization, which accepts deposits that can be withdrawn on
demand. It also lends money to individuals and business houses that need it.
Banks also render many other useful services – like collection of bills,
payment of foreign bills, safe-keeping of jewelers and other valuable items,
certifying the credit-worthiness of business, and so on. Banks accept deposits
from the general public as well as from the business community. Anyone who
saves money for future can deposit his savings in a bank.
E-Banking
System:
Banking activity carried on
through computers and other electronic means of communication is called
‘electronic banking’ or ‘E-Banking’.3 E-Banking or Electronic banking refers to conducting banking activities
with the help of information technology (IT) and computers. Computerization of
banking functions in India was resisted by labour
unions for fear of loss of job opportunities. Secondly, computerization needs
IT savvy personnel which require intensive technical training. Thirdly,
computerization needs heavy capital outlay for purchase of machines. Fourthly,
to have effective computerization of banks a large number of bank branches
situated in rural areas need to be connected. Telecommunication facility at
rural areas is slow to reach. For the reasons mentioned above, computerization
made a slow entry in Indian banks.4
Boons and Banes of E-Banking System
Functions of E-Banking system:
At present, the personal e-bank system provides the number of services, such as, Inquiry about the
information of account, Card accounts' transfer, Bank-securities accounts
transfer, The transaction of foreign exchange, The B2C disbursement on net, Client
service, Account management, Reporting the loss of the account, Pay a bill,
Track payment history, etc.
Disadvantages of E-Banking:
If there are advantages in
venturing to E-Banking, there are also disadvantages. Even the pioneers of
E-Banking are not sure of what this technology can bring in the future
.Here are some of the issues/arguments5: Such as,
When
using an Internet banking account, the account owner may have no face to face
interaction with a bank employee if the bank does not have a brick and mortar
location. This can make resolving disputes more difficult as the account holder
will have to make a phone call and possibly wait on hold, or be forced to send
an email.6 Traditional banks will find it difficult to evolve. With this issue, it’s very
simple, even though the concept of E-Banking is about doing transactions
with ease, trying to evolve into one is difficult. It really requires study,
and analyzing competitors and using advertising as a main weapon to
attract consumers.7 The
start-up costs of an e-bank are high. Starting this kind of
technology requires a large amount; this covers the advertising expenditure,
and the purchasing of the said technology.8 It sometimes takes more time to Start-up, have to pay Bank Site Charges
etc.
E – Banking Frauds in India
“Lapses in system make easy the
job of offenders to dupe banks”9
Computer crimes are different
from the usual crime, vis-ŕ-vis investigations. Here, the criminals has just to
drum a key board and drums of money are taken away, no personal exposure, no
written documents, no signature, no finger prints, no voice. The criminal is
truly faceless. The commission of Computer crimes is done with lightening speed
without leaving any trace relating to time element. Computer crimes are of varied nature.10
The Information Technology is increasingly harnessing in a big way to bring in
greater efficiency, accuracy and speed in the business. Computer crimes are
those committed with a computer theft, forgery, counter-fecting
etc.11
Any illegal behavior directed by
means of electronic operations that targets the security of computer systems
and the data processed by them is termed as cyber crime. Cyber crime in a
broader sense is computer-related crime.12
Types of E-Banking frauds:
Offline fraud and Online fraud.13
Most offline fraud incidences happen as a result of theft of your mail,
sensitive information related to your bank or credit card accounts, stolen ATM/debit/credit
cards, forged/ stolen cheques etc. You can protect
yourself from such instances by exercising caution while receiving, storing and
disposing your account statements as well as your cheques,
ATM/debit and credit cards. Online fraud occurs when someone poses as a
legitimate company that may or may not be in order to obtain sensitive personal
data and illegally conducts transactions on your existing accounts. Often
called “phishing” (An online identity theft scam. Typically, criminals send emails
that look like they're from legitimate sources, but are not. The fake messages
generally include a link to phony, or spoofed, websites, where victims are
asked to provide sensitive personal information. The information goes to
criminals, rather than the legitimate business.) Or “spoofing” (An online identity theft scam. Typically, criminals send
emails that look like they're from legitimate sources, but are not (phishing).
The fake messages generally include a link to phony, or spoofed, websites,
where victims are asked to provide sensitive personal information. The
information goes to criminals, rather than the legitimate business.) , the most current methods of online fraud
are usually through fake emails, Web sites and pop-up windows, or any combination
of such methods.
Legal Frame Work for E – Banking System in India
Internet Banking, with its
ability to reach each and every nook and cranny of the world holds great
importance for a nation like India, where conventional Banking services are out
of reach for a large proportion of the masses. But to make it a success it
requires more than just an adequate internet enabling infrastructure. There is
a dire need for an adequate legal and regulatory framework to be put into
place.
Electronic Banking or Banking Over Electronic Medium:
All banking transactions and
Services carried or availed by the Customer other than by direct personal
interface with the branch of the Bank such as over telephone, ATM, Net-Banking,
Mobile Phone, fax, kiosks or other electronic mediums are referred to as
"Banking over an Electronic Medium or Electronic Banking". The
facility of Electronic Banking is provided as a convenience to the Customer
only and it is implicit in the Customer availing this facility that the Customer
recognizes that the Bank will not preserve any record of the instructions given
by the Customer for availing this facility and hence the Customer will not
contest any transaction carried out or not carried out by the Bank, over
Electronic Banking, shall accept the record of the transaction maintained by
the Bank, without any demur or protest, and hold the Bank harmless and
blameless against any loss, or consequences thereof, arising from any
transaction carried out or not carried out over Electronic Banking. Against the
above Cancel ground, the Customer can use any services provided by the Bank
over Electronic Bank. Some of the Services, which the Customer can avail over
Electronic Banking and conditions of such Services are given below14:
Withdrawal of Electronic Banking:
The Bank without assigning any
reason shall be entitled to withdraw from any of its Customers
Electronic-Banking facility or any one or more of them. Without prejudice to
the foregoing, the Bank shall also be entitled to withdraw such facility if:15
The minimum balance requirement
in respect of the Customer / user accounts is not met with / fulfilled and / or
the service charges remain unpaid and /or for any other or no reason. In event
the Electronic Banking is withdrawn, it shall neither be obligation for the
Bank to give any notice to the Customer nor shall the Bank incur any liability
whatsoever by reason of withdrawal of Electronic Banking.
RBI Guidelines for Internet
Banking:
The Reserve Bank of India had
set up a 'Working Group on Internet Banking' to examine different aspects of
Internet Banking (I-banking). The Group had focused on three major areas of
I-banking, i.e, Technology and security
issues, Legal issues and Regulatory and supervisory issues. A copy of
the Group's report is enclosed. RBI has accepted the recommendations of the
Group to be implemented in a phased manner. Accordingly, the following
guidelines are issued for implementation by banks.16
Legal Issues:
a) Considering the legal position
prevalent, there is an obligation on the part of banks not only to establish
the identity but also to make enquiries about integrity and reputation of the
prospective customer. Therefore, even though request for opening account can be
accepted over Internet, accounts should be opened only after proper
introduction and physical verification of the identity of the customer. 17
b) From a legal perspective,
security procedure adopted by banks for authenticating users needs to be
recognized by law as a substitute for signature. In India, the Information Technology Act, 2000, in Section 3(2) provides
for a particular technology (viz., the asymmetric crypto system and hash
function) as a means of authenticating electronic record. Any other method used
by banks for authentication should be recognized as a source of legal risk.
c) Under the present regime there
is an obligation on banks to maintain secrecy and confidentiality of customers'
accounts. The banks should, therefore, institute adequate risk control measures
to manage such risks.
d) In Internet banking scenario
there is very little scope for the banks to act on stop-payment instructions
from the customers. Hence, banks should clearly notify to the customers the
time frame and the circumstances in which any stop-payment instructions could
be accepted.
e) The Consumer Protection Act, 1986 defines the rights of consumers
in India and is applicable to banking services as well. Currently, the rights
and liabilities of customers availing of Internet banking services are being
determined by bilateral agreements between the banks and customers. Considering
the E-Banking practice and rights enjoyed by customers in traditional banking,
banks' liability to the customers on account of unauthorized transfer through
hacking, denial of service on account of technological failure etc. needs to be
assessed and banks providing Internet banking should insure themselves against
such risks.
III. Regulatory and Supervisory Issues:
The existing regulatory
framework over banks will be extended to Internet banking also. In this regard,
it is advised that:
1. Only such banks which are
licensed and supervised in India and have a physical presence in India will be
permitted to offer Internet banking products to residents of India. Thus, both
banks and virtual banks incorporated outside the country and having no physical
presence in India will not, for the present, be permitted to offer Internet
banking services to Indian residents.18
2. The products should be
restricted to account holders only and should not be offered in other
jurisdictions19.
3. The 'in-out' scenario where
customers in cross border jurisdictions are offered banking services by Indian
banks (or branches of foreign banks in India) and the 'out-in' scenario where
Indian residents are offered banking services by banks operating in
cross-border jurisdictions are generally not permitted and this approach will
apply to Internet banking also. The existing exceptions for limited purposes
under FEMA i.e. where resident Indians have been permitted to continue to
maintain their accounts with overseas banks etc., will, however, be
permitted. 20
4. Overseas branches of Indian
banks will be permitted to offer Internet banking services to their overseas
customers subject to their satisfying, in addition to the host supervisor, the
home supervisor.21
Effective Cybercrime Legislation:
As part of the global efforts to
promote e-commerce trust and confidence, every nation should have basic
criminal laws against activities that attack the confidentiality, integrity or
availability of computer data, computer system and electronic networks. In
order to flight cyber crime, there is a need to clarify what constitutes an
offence or a crime, especially in a global context when prosecution of
transnational illegal activities would be expected. Governments should agree on
the definitions of certain crimes committed in the Internet environment. Laws
would need to be enacted to criminalize hacking, illegal interception,
interference with the availability of computers and networks and unlawful
access to system.22
An attempt to address the
international nature of cybercrime and develop a common standard for cybercrime
law was made by the Council of Europe (COE) in the Convention on Cybercrime
that was publicized in its final form in June 2001. The Commonwealth also
published a Model Law on Computer and Computer Related Crimes that was
published in October 2002. The model law was developed by an expert group while
reviewing the details of the provisions in the Convention on Cybercrime.23
The main intent of the COE Convention
is to pursue a common criminal policy aimed at the protection of society
against cybercrime, by adopting appropriate legislation and fostering
international cooperation, among other activities. The Convention includes a
list of crimes and requires that certain activities be criminalized. These
include such activities as hacking (including production, sale or distribution
of hacking tools); offence relating to child pornography and expanded criminal
liability for intellectual property violations. It also requires each signatory
state to implement surveillance powers as well as the duty of governments to
help each other gather evidence and enforce laws.24
Finally, the Convention requires
signatory states to provide international cooperation to the widest extent
possible for investigations and proceedings concerning criminal offence related
to computer systems and data or for collecting evidence in electronic form of a
criminal offence. Law cooperates with their requests for assistance in the
pursuit of criminals across national borders, something that is common in
Internet Crime.25
Evidence and cyber law
Evidence is information that
tends to prove or disprove a fact in question. Evidence may consist of
documents, public records, affidavits or the testimony of witnesses. The law of
evidence is a part of the law of procedure. The
Indian Evidence Act applies to all judicial proceedings before any court
material. According to the United Nation
Commission on International Trade law (UNCITRAL) on Electronic Commerce (Article 7), information shall not be denied
legal effect, validity or enforceability solely on the grounds that it is in
the form of a data message. According to Article
6, where the law requires information to be in writing, that requirement should
be met by a data message if the information contained therein is accessible so
as to be usable for subsequent reference. Article
8 states as where the law requires information to be presented or retained
in its original form, that requirement are met by a data message.26
The Indian Evidence Act 1872 does not define a computer but allows
for copies to be made by mechanical processes. Reference to computer and media
are made as regards Evidence in the Companies Act, 1956. There are number of
provisions applicable to electronic records etc., such as section 17, 18, 19,
20, 21, 22A, 32, 34, 35, 45, 46, 51, 57, 58, 60, 73,159 of The Indian Evidence
Act 1872.
An admission is a statement oral
or documentary or contained in electronic form, which suggests any inference as
to ay fact in issue or relevant fact and which is made by any of the persons
and under the circumstances, hereinafter mentioned.27 A new section 22A28 has been inserted to provide for
relevance of oral admissions as to contents of electronic records in certain
circumstances. It applies to circumstances where, the electronic record is a
primary evidence.
Entries in books of accounts
including those maintained in an electronic form when relevant.29
Relevancy of entry in public record or an electronic record made in performance
of duty is also relevant.30
Other relevant provisions:
The Indian Information
Technology Act, 2000, basically a framework law, makes hacking a punishable
offence under Section 66. Breach of
information security is implicitly recognized as a penal offence in the
form hacking. The
‘appropriate government’ (central/state) is empowered to declare any
‘computer’, ‘computer system’ or ‘computer network’ as a protected
system. A ten year prison term and a hefty fine await any person who
secures access to the ‘secured computer system’ in contravention of the
provisions of the law. 31
In keeping with the view that
law should be technology neutral, thus Section 3(2) of the Information
Technology Act, 2000 needs to be amended to provide that in addition to the
procedure prescribed there in or that may be prescribed by the Central
government, a security procedure mutually agreed to by the concerned parties
should be recognized as a valid method of authentication of an electronic document
/ transaction during the transition period.
Banks may be allowed to apply
for a license to issue digital signature certificate under Section 21 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 and function as
certifying authority for facilitating Internet banking. Reserve Bank of India
may recommend to Central Government for notifying the business of certifying
authority as an approved activity under clause (o) of Section 6(1) of the
E-Banking Regulations Act, 1949.
Section 415 to 42032, detail the law relating to cheating. In
the case of Internet Scams relevant sections relevant sections relating to the
crime of cheating such as cheating by impersonation (section 416)33
cheating with knowledge that wrongful loss may ensure to person where interest
if offender is bound to protect (section 418)34, etc. may be applied
according to the facts of the case.35
Section 40A(3) of the Income Tax
Act, 1961 recognizes only payments through a crossed cheque or crossed bank
draft, where such payment exceeds Rs. 20000/-, for the purpose of deductible
expenses. Since the primary intention of the above provision, which is to
prevent tax evasion by ensuring transfer of funds through identified accounts,
is also satisfied in case of electronic transfer of funds between accounts,
such transfers should also be recognized under the above provision. The Income
Tax Act, 1961 should be amended suitably.
The Consumer Protection Act,
1986 defines the rights of consumers in India and is applicable to banking
services as well. Currently, the rights and liabilities of customers availing
of Internet banking services are being determined by bilateral agreements
between the banks and customers. It is open to debate whether any bilateral
agreement defining customers rights and liabilities, which are adverse to
consumers than what is enjoyed by them in the traditional banking scenario will
be legally tenable. Considering the E-Banking practice and rights enjoyed by
customers in traditional banking, it appears the banks providing I-banking may
not absolve themselves from liability to the customers on account of
unauthorized transfer through hacking. Similar position may obtain in case of
denial of service. Even though, The Information Technology Act, 2000 has
provided for penalty for denial of access to a computer system (Section-43) and
hacking (Section – 66), the liability of banks in such situations is not clear.
So, that the banks providing Internet banking may assess the risk and insure
themselves against such risks.
Electronic Funds Transfer Act:
In 1995, the Reserve Bank had
set up the Committee for Proposing Legislation on Electronic Funds Transfer and
other Electronic Payments (Chairperson : Smt. K.S.Shere).
The Shere Committee had recommended a set of EFT
Regulations by the Reserve Bank under the Reserve Bank of India Act, m1934 and
amendment to the Bankers’ Books Evidence Act, 1881 as short term measures and
promotion of a few Acts like the Electronic Funds Transfer Act, the Computer
Misuse and Data Protection Act etc. as long term measures. The Reserve Bank has
already initiated steps for framing of EFT Regulations.36 The
Government of India have also initiated steps for promoting Information and
Technology Act, 1999 and consequential amendments to the Reserve Bank of India
Act, 1934, the Bankers’ Books Evidence Act, 1881 etc.
Admission of electronic files as evidence and preservation of
records:
The Shere
Committee had discussed the issues of admitting electronic files as evidence
and of preserving electronic records and recommended the need to amend the
Bankers' Books Evidence Act, 1881 on the lines of the Customs and Central
Excise Laws (Amendment) Act, 1988 and Central Excise and Salt Act, 1944 for the
purpose. It is learnt that Government of India is processing the draft Bill
amending the Bankers’ Books Evidence Act, 1881. This is a welcome development
and would meet the legal requirement of acceptance of contracts, documents etc.
in electronic form as evidence.37 The Committee considered certain
provisions of the proposed Electronic Commerce Bill for admitting electronic
records / signatures as evidence. Clauses 9, 10, 11, 12 and 14 of this proposed
Bill which is relevant in this connection. 38
Thus, this chapter systematize
the laws prevail in India in simply manner. The Indian Government is aware of
the positive and negative potential of the Information Technology, Indian Penal
Code 1860, Indian Evidence Act (1872) and Criminal Procedure Code (1973). It is
apparent that new laws have to be framed to handle the Cyber Crimes, the conartist and the intangible evidence thereof. The Reserve
Bank of India has come up with in handling computer crimes under Electronic
Fund Transfer Act and Rules, Amendment to the Reserve Bank of India,
The-Banking Regulation Act, Bankers Book Evidence Act.
Necessary amendment has made in
the Information Technology Act, 2000 towards the laws both legal luminaries and
Cyber specialists are involved. The Indian experience in the actual functioning
of the Information Technology is limited. Experience of the developed countries
can be fully utilized by organizations which have developed expertise in this
field are:
·
Organization for European Cooperation and Development (OECD) has
already issued a set of guidelines.
·
The United Nation Organization has published a Crime Control
Manual.
·
Countries like US, UK, Germany, Japan, France etc, has framed laws
to computer frauds,
CONCLUSION:
The IT revolution had a great
impact in the Indian banking system. The use of computers had led to
introduction of online E-Banking in India. The use of the modern innovation and
computerization of the E-Banking sector of India has increased many folds after
the economic liberalization of 1991 as the country's banking sector has been
exposed to the world's market. The evolution of electronic banking products has
made day to day banking operations faster and more efficient. The increased
productivity gained through the use of electronic banking products has allowed
businesses to do more with less. Businesses that do not use some form of electronic
banking products will not grow.
The popular services covered
under E-Banking are; Automated Teller Machines, Credit Cards, Debit Cards,
Smart Cards, Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) System, Cheques
Truncation, Payment System, Mobile-Banking, Internet Banking, Telephone
E-Banking, etc.
As we know each every coin has
two sides, thus, E-Banking has a number of good impact or advantages along with
number of defects. Advantages like, the operating cost per unit services is
lower for the banks, it offers convenience to customers as they are not
required to go to the bank's premises, there is very low incidence of errors,
the customer can obtain funds at any time from ATM machines, the credit cards
and debit cards enables the Customers to obtain discounts from retail outlets,
The customer can easily transfer the funds from one place to another place
electronically, etc.
Along with number of advantages,
there are lots of disadvantages which create various security problems. This
ultimately results that E-Banking is not safe. No, doubt Indian government took
lots of steps through Reserve Bank of India; or through judiciary; or by
enacting different areas of laws, but still exercising the system of E-Banking
is not safe and day by day frauds in this area goes on rapidly. The main
disadvantage of E-Banking is the security problems that surround it. It's a
fact that making transactions online poses a much bigger risk compared to
making transactions in a physical branch. This is due to the hacking problems
and identity theft. Addition to these risks, technical difficulties could also
arise. Sometimes the bank's website goes down, and if this happens it will be a
hassle for the customer because he/she has to go to a branch or make phone
calls, which are usually busy due to other customers also making a call.
Another case that has happened was an unpredicted rise in customer that the
servers of the bank were not able to cope with. A customer may also run
into a bad service. Sometimes one might wait a while for checks to clear and
certainly can't do anything about it if it is online.
These disadvantages of E-Banking
system ultimately resulted to great challenges for security of the customer in
India, such as:
·
Government facing challenge of enacting proper regulation and legality,
as because E-Banking system provides services to all over the world. Thus, it
is tough for a country for regulatory authorities to enforce finance laws
throughout the globe. Additionally, regulations differ from nation to nation
and banks are not always proficient in the financial laws for every nation in
which they have business.
·
Customer facing security problem because of hacking into the
bank's server in order to acquire bank account data, or a software glitch might
cause the bank to unwittingly distribute personal data to the wrong person.
From the statistical data it can be trace out that year by year fraud in this
respect goes on. It’s a challenge for the regulator to control these E-Banking
frauds, no doubt still now India there is number of provisions for proper
regulation of this system.
·
Another challenge such as governance and security has the
potential to make a bank look bad to clients. Additionally, the more a bank
relies on Internet banking, the more the bank may gain an impersonal feel. Both
of these problems may discourage clients from choosing a bank that relies on
E-Banking, regardless of how convenient E-Banking may be.
·
A major challenge facing is related to legal risk. That is, Banks
can potentially expand the geographical scope of their services faster through
electronic banking than through traditional banks. In some cases, however, they
might not be fully versed in the jurisdiction of local laws and regulations
before they begin to offer services there, either with a license or without a
license if one is not required. When a license is not required, a virtual
bank—lacking contact with its host country supervisor - may find it even more
difficult to stay abreast of regulatory changes. As a consequence, virtual
banks could unknowingly violate customer protection laws, including on data
collection and privacy, and regulations on soliciting. In doing so, they expose
themselves to losses through lawsuits or crimes that are not prosecuted because
of jurisdictional disputes.
·
Other challenges like there are risks associated with onlin E-Banking that one should be aware of. Unfortunately,
technology is never 100 percent reliable. One may have trouble connecting to
the Internet. The bank's website may be temporarily down. If one has not left his
time to get to the branch or contact it by phone, then the person are at risk
of missing payment deadlines, which will result in penalty charges. OnlinE-Banking can also compromise one’s security and
privacy. Hackers can obtain one’s account number or Social Security number and
make unauthorized transactions on that person’s behalf. Someone may get ones
security details if that person didn't close the browser window or if the
password memorization feature is enabled for his bank's website.
Hence, there are ample numbers
of challenges for regulating the system of E-Banking. It can be concluded that,
E-Banking carry out a way to simplifies the work of bank and bank’s customers,
along with it carry ample areas of problems or challenges; danger of security etc.
Even we can trace out from the above work that, in a fraud case, bank always be
in a safer side. In a judgment, State Consumer Redressal
Commission stated that, net banking fraud is not bank fraud as because, bank
already mentioned about the risks involved in net banking system in the
security transaction. Even we can find that in the terms and condition of the
bank there are specifically mention in each and every ground that bank is not
responsible or liable.
Bank provides the system and
bank itself is in a position, that no one can make the bank liable for any loss
cause due to fraud. A person make an account in a bank for transact its money,
having a trust and believe of security of his money by the bank. And at that
time, the bank stated in one side that bank will take care of that money and in
other side it stated that bank will not be liable for any E-Banking fraud.
That, bank will not safe for money transaction.
So, there should be systematic
guideline, rules and regulation, proper techniques, secured software for the
bank who provides banking system. Legal frame work should be strong enough.
Along with this, there should be proper penalty for the criminal and other
member of the conspiracy and along with this; there should be proper relief for
the victim. For that there should be specific, systematic, separate procedure
and everything should be based on benefit of the customer only.
Thus the hypothesis has been
proved as E-Banking is having both the aspect in respect of boon and bane to
the society. E- Banking is really slow in its pace in India in comparison to
the worldly picture and pace, thus giving a huge area for the laws and
regulations to flourish in this field of technological revolution in India. In
response to the rampant E- Banking frauds, the stringency of the regulation
should cope to combat the illegality caused by it.
REFERENCE:
1. Quotes on E-Banking, Available
From: http://www.scribd.com/FaizanShamsi/d/53136058/24-SCOPE-OF-THE-STUDY.
2. E – Banking system ppt, Available From:
http://www.scribd.com/doc/13521847/E-BANKING,
3. Ppt on definition of E-Banking
system, Available From: http://www.scribd.com/doc/26494919/ Definition-of-E-banking,
5. Advantages and disadvantages of
E-Banking, Available From:
http://john.articlealley.com/the-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-internet-banking-2404480.html.
6. Advantages & Disadvantages
of E-Banking system, Available From:
http://www.ehow.com/facts_4744500_advantages-disadvantages-internet-banking.html.
7. Blog on advantages and
disadvantages of internet banking, Available From: http://paulgoodman67.hubpages.com/hub/The-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-internet-banking,
8. ibid
9. Legal Service India.com, Bank
Frauds Available From: http://www.legalserviceindia.com/
article/l261-Bank-Frauds.html,
10. C Vidya;
Cyber Crimes and Laws- An Overview;
2007; page no.113
11. Ibid; page no. 114
12. Concept of cyber crime,
Available From:
http://webuser.hs-furtwangen.de/~heindl/ebte-08ss-law-in-business-Krishan.pdf;
13. Types of internet fraud,
Available From: http://www.silverinnings.com/docs/Fin ance/Frauds/Types%20of%20Internet
%20Fraud.pdf.
14. Electronic Banking Or Banking
Over Electronic Medium, rules and regulation of internet banking, Available
From:
https://www.onlinesbiglobal.com/64BE/web/SBI/Disclaimer.htm.
15. Withdrawl Of Electronic Banking, rules
and regulation of internet banking, Available From: https:// www.onlinesbiglobal.com
/64BE/web/SBI/Disclaimer.htm.
16. Internet banking in India,
guidelines, 14th june 2001, Available
From: http://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/notification/ PDFs/21569.pdf.
17. Legal issues, Internet banking
in India, guidelines, 14th june 2001,
Available From: http://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/notification/ PDFs/21569.pdf.
18. Regulatory and supervisory
issues, Internet banking in India, guidelines, 14th june 2001, Available From: http://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/notification/
PDFs/21569.pdf.
19. ibid
20. ibid
21. ibid
22. C Vidya;
Cyber Crimes and Laws- An Overview;
2007; page no. 09
23. ibid
24. ibid
25. The Convention has had its
detractors, however. Available From:
http://crime-research.org/library/CoE_Cybercrime.html this paper focuses on the
wide scope of powers accorded to the law enforcement agencies under the
Convention.
26. C Vidya;
Cyber Crimes and Laws- An Overview;
2007; page no.92
27. Section 17 The Indian Evidence
Act, 1872
28. The Indian Evidence Act, 1872
29. Section 34 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872
30. Section 35 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872
31. Indian Information Technology
Act, Available From:
http://www.arraydev.com/commerce/JIBC/2006-04/gupta.HTM
32. Indian Penal Code, 1860
33. ibid
34. ibid
35.
V.D.Dudeja; Cyber Crimes and Law- Crimes in Cyber Space – Scams and Frauds- Volume
– I;2002, page no. 124
36. V.D.Dudeja; Cyber Crimes and Law- Crimes in Cyber Space – Scams and Frauds- Volume
– I;2002
37. ibid
38. ibid
Received on 11.11.2014 Modified on 05.12.2014
Accepted on 15.01.2015 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Management 6(1):
January–March, 2015 page 53-60
DOI: 10.5958/2321-5763.2015.00009.8